> rrealita said on
11-30-2009 at
20:50:
@daddy3189 I don't agree, this is more emotional, this is original.. just listen it, makes me cry
> blocparty4eva1 said on
11-30-2009 at
14:38:
makes me cry every time
> Arschkratzer said on
11-30-2009 at
13:10:
this song you could only understand if you were addicted...
> daddy3189 said on
11-30-2009 at
07:36:
Johnny Cash made this song so much more powerful! his song gave me the chills when he sang it. JC is amazing! but up's to Nine Inch Nails for the lyrics!
> claudiaatyzo said on
11-30-2009 at
05:23:
cashs version owns this gay shit
> NidsForMe said on
11-29-2009 at
22:54:
jc sings it darker but he does use his life experience to sing it
> casgigolo said on
11-29-2009 at
21:04:
@et13603 of course Trent wrote this song Johnny Cash covered itby the way this song has an amazing lyrics
> JesusIsComing said on
11-29-2009 at
18:48:
@et13603 Dude, Trent Reznor wrote this song.
> SladenXtreme said on
11-29-2009 at
14:42:
This is so beautiful live. I don't understand the debate between the Cash cover and this. They are both amazing and both bring me to tears. Just enjoy the words and music friends.
> KillCoopLoops said on
11-29-2009 at
08:45:
are all of you inSANE?! trent reznor is a genius and johnny never would have written this song... it's too dark, even for johnny... though he does do an excellent cover of it... nothing can compare to the original... JC does sing about hardships... but have you listened to ANY NIN? regardless of WHO sings it, however, the meaning is always heartfelt.
> firewall666777 said on
11-29-2009 at
06:16:
I don't know it's hard to compare JC and NIN but I'd say a person who had never heard music would choose Johnny's. I don't know who NIN is directing it to or about but I know Johnny sings about his whole life which makes it better to me. He is 70 and sings about all of his hardships, giving me goosebumps is what makes Johnny's better to me. RIP JC
> LouGiblin said on
11-29-2009 at
03:42:
I like johnnys version 'cause it is his life story. You can tell he was also singing about June leaving him. Makes you want to cry when he sings it.
> crawdaddy500 said on
11-29-2009 at
01:54:
your probably the only person on here who is mature enough and respectable enough to listen to this song. Thanks for your grounded comment.
> YugiohMaster199 said on
11-28-2009 at
23:23:
I liked Cash's version better, but listening to this live version, I may have to reconsider. His voice live is heart wrenching. Amazing song!
> kuwaimaha said on
11-28-2009 at
23:22:
i prefer jhonny's version. it seems more powerful.
> Pi8ikorockas96 said on
11-28-2009 at
21:42:
@et13603 what do u mean they didnt write this song? its not johnny cash's. johnny cash actually covered it. im pretty sure its nin's
> et13603 said on
11-28-2009 at
21:40:
they didnt write this song, you know that. and if you don't like them, don't post. I'm not a fan, but no need to spam. just an all around amazing song mate.\
> Pi8ikorockas96 said on
11-28-2009 at
21:17:
@ryangabb NIN just sucks. i cant really imagine haow they managed to write such an amazing song
> ryangabb said on
11-28-2009 at
15:00:
I don't really like NIN but this is amazing, not as good as Johnny's version but still amazing.
> Vrublevskogo said on
11-28-2009 at
00:49:
NIN Forever
eMule
games
software
videos
> Emule > Videos > Hurt > Nine Inch Nails - Hurt
