I agree. I didn't like the vibe Prue gave off. She always had to be in control and her powers seemed like so much stronger than the other two. But when Paige came on the scene, her powers were cool, but she never overwhelmed the other two. It was always a good balance. And you could tell the three actresses had fun. Whereas when Prue was on, there always seemed to be tension between the three...I think...

I liked rose, she made the show great. Seemed tension was gone and they had fun. I agree Cole should have stayed and he probably would have had a reunion with phoebe if the actor didn't want to join another tv series. Pity cos i liked him alot :)

i agree you can see the fun they had,i didnt like rose eaither,but the tension was gone,the attitude was better,and the show more fun,the only wrong was the killing off of cole,they need to come back and fix that,love julian,and him,and phoebes chemistry was beyond great......

she left becuse she knew she was wrong,its called guilty conciuse.good ridens.

why are you all aginst alyisa,shanon has been the trouble maker on more than one set,she couldnt just do her job,why is that everybody hates the one girl who has never caused problms on any set,or have had reported diva attitude,like shannen,good riddens...

They needed to lose phoebe and keep prue.

Shannen should of stayed on and they should of dropped Alyssa plain and simple. I never liked Paige but i think it had less to do with the actress and more to do with Prue leaving. Charmed sucked after season three and wasnt even worth watching and the billie crap was even worse. Shannen forever :)

she was never invited. Brad Kern didn't even want her to come back. Shannen said she would've done it for free. Yes I know this comment is old, but it needs to be said.

Actually, Prue I mean... Shannen, left herself. She was upset with people not taking her seriously on the show, so she got out of her contract and left the show.

Paige is great about her character ,powers and abilities but I wish she could have met Prue...And I couldn't imagine what would they react if they met each other ( with Paige being human and Prue being ghost )...I still miss Shannen Doherty as Prue ...

they didnt actually say that they kicked her off, she might have left and shannen doherty said she left on her own. she wanted a better acting career so she left.

Actually, she was a biotch on set so they killed her off. Though, Pru is one o0f the greatest sisters, other than Paige

Don't blame the actress the writers did that. OKay!! I always liked Rose. She dated Marilyn Manson come on the girl is funny and sexy First born children often have to take on more . The 4 th season was one the best with the seer

my theroy is prue the actress was gettingtoo oldand they needed a fresh young blood

I love Paige, I was never a big fan of Prue, she used to annoy me. Rose did a brilliant job, and altho Paige and Piper were never as close as Piper and Prue, I think Phoebe and Paige definetely were closer and had alot more chemistry as actresses, than Phoebe and Prue. Don't stress out, its just my thoughts

LOL piper with Kaka-merry rules aahaahahahah

paige breathed new life into the show! her character was witty and funny and a total blast, but i have always thought that the original three had better chemistry. too bad shannon doherty had to trip the circuit, god she's so full of herself!!!! rose is a much more interesting person.....

Love prue love paige they did a great job cast rose as paige and its oke that shannen left. The show neither got better or worse IT STAYED CHARMED

no offense or anything but i kind of disliked the show a little after shannen left only because she was an original character with huge shoes to fill. and rose didn't even come close to filling them. PRUE FOREVER.<3

tahst coz she was the best no other way to get around that