> avietdung said on
12-12-2009 at
03:54:
yes,Susan understand song than .but Elaine still good in emocation
> BBCEREISS said on
12-10-2009 at
20:05:
It's not as touching as the Susan Boyle's way.
> reokdsp said on
12-10-2009 at
18:16:
Susan has a sweeter voice.
> captainddgolf said on
12-10-2009 at
11:28:
Don't! quite follow the visuals but the singing is superb
> caravaggio31 said on
12-10-2009 at
08:03:
Susan has more range but of course Elaine has great technics, Susan needs lesson to improve.She's a wild horse give her care and guidance and she will be a new Elaine or even more.
> attkmast3r said on
12-09-2009 at
23:45:
S U S A N B O Y L E I S B E T T E R!
> soulfanatiko said on
12-07-2009 at
14:13:
Ruthie Henshall is the BEST VERSION EVER!
> C8l8o8u8d said on
12-06-2009 at
21:23:
My personal favorite is Ruthie's version - she has the most power and emotion.However, it's impossible to deny that Elaine and Susan have incredible talent. Elaine sings Memory perfectly, and Susan shows great potential.
> 210357tommy said on
12-05-2009 at
04:27:
i being a welshman have to agree with a lot of you.firstly this not the best recording of elaine singing this song.but however susan boyle has got a fantastic voice,no doubt about that.if you listened to both today i do not think you could compare.but for any critics listen to elaine page in musicals by andrew loyd webber?good luck and best wishes to susan and elaine may you both live long to give us many happy years of fantastic talent. love from WALESxxxxxxxxxxx
> lankylad50 said on
12-04-2009 at
21:25:
Forget all this....they are all brilliant. My Wife bent my ear for two years or so to go to see Les Mis in London. I (pillock) just didn't fancy it......pillock. If you have not seen it sell your Grannie and get a ticket. This song is just one of a number of fabulous numbers. Please, please. please go and see it!
> trackerdog1969 said on
12-04-2009 at
17:36:
Elaine Paige is a natural for God sake I remember listening to her as a kid back home now some 25 years on she is still at it. Will the likes of Susan Boyle still be at it in 25 years time. people need to get in the real world instead of jumping on the reality TV show band wagon. Yes Susan Boyle has a good voice but people put her on such a pedestal. No wonder she acts like a loon !!
> tubekwt said on
12-03-2009 at
01:39:
Although I like the songs of Elaine Paige, I felt Susan sang it in a slightly better way. Susan has a strong natural voice. However Elaine sang Memory in the best way possible.
> azurebird1 said on
12-03-2009 at
00:17:
Love it! You really can't compare Elaine, Ruthie or Susan. They're all different people. Elain sang it great, but (to me) she sings Memory with perfection.
> AnnaGanina said on
12-01-2009 at
19:01:
oh My God....She is perfect!!!
> lordantzu said on
12-01-2009 at
18:15:
Ruthie Henshall I feel is better than both of them.listen to her and then you will see what I mean.
> Franknarf94 said on
12-01-2009 at
14:02:
Susan Boyle sings the song better.
> FiberMania said on
12-01-2009 at
13:00:
This is my first time ever listening to Elaine Paige. She and Susan have similar tone in their voices and somewhat different styles. Paige is obviously a very gifted top rate vocalist. Honestly I would have to say that Susan Boyle is right there with her talent wise. Elainie may be a tiny bit more refined, but Susan is far more dynamic.
> RandyEconomy said on
12-01-2009 at
02:48:
She is NO SUSAN BOYLE....fer sure!
> tellsouthgate said on
11-30-2009 at
21:20:
second rate
> Wzershart said on
11-30-2009 at
20:38:
Jeez, I can't get the time good.What I wanted to say was:"She made a pop song of it at 3:34..."Finally!
eMule
games
software
videos
> Emule > Videos > Elaine > Elaine Paige - I Dreamed A Dream (Live In Concert)
